Monday, January 28, 2013
Mistakes of the Judicial Branch
Our
Judicial Branch has a bit of a rough history.
While it has made mostly good calls in its lifetime, I believe that it
has there have been some times when they’ve made some bad choices, or weren’t
completely in control of what they were supposed to be. One such instance was
when the issue of whether or not to make the Native American’s move to designated
areas. The Supreme Court was charged
with making the decision, and they decided that it was unconstitutional to make
them move, which I think was the right choice.
However, the president didn’t agree with them and decided to go ahead
and make all of the Native Americans move to the places that we weren’t going
to use. The system didn’t work the way
it was supposed to. There were also times when the judicial branch has made
decisions that were completely unfair, especially when looking at them by today’s
views. Back in the 1920s a black man
named Homer Plessy filed a lawsuit against a railway system because they forced
him to sit in a separate train car than white people. Courts kept ruling against him, and he kept
bringing the case to higher and higher courts. Eventually the case made it to
the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court
ruled against Plessy, saying that separating people by race still kept them
equal. This introduced segregation as a
lawful and accepted practice. Back then
it probably wasn’t so easy to realize the unfairness, but today almost everyone
sees it. As you can see, courts around America
have made many mistakes, even the Supreme Court. The judicial branch has not always worked the
way that it was supposed to, and will probably continue to make mistakes in its
judgment, even if those mistakes aren’t recognized for years to come.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)